Advertisement
CONFESSION #0368 — APPRAISAL DISASTER
Monday, March 16, 2026
Appraiser shows up Tuesday and I'm feeling good because comps are solid, house is clean, everything's buttoned up. He's in there maybe twenty minutes which... fine, whatever, some of them are fast.
Report comes back this morning. He used a comp that sold eight months ago. A SHORT SALE. From a divorce where they just wanted out. And somehow missed the three houses on the same street that closed in the last sixty days at full asking.
We're now $67,000 under contract price. Sixty seven thousand dollars.
My buyers are freaking out, sellers are threatening to walk, and I've already spent two hours on the phone with the lender trying to figure out if we can request a reconsideration of value. Which apparently requires me to basically do the appraiser's job FOR him and submit my own comps with a formal rebuttal letter.
The best part? I looked him up and he's based 45 minutes away in a completely different market. Probably doesn't even know this neighborhood exists.
Anyway I have to go write a three page letter now explaining why a short sale isn't comparable to a normal transaction
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF INVOLUNTARY VICTIMHOOD IN THE FIRST DEGREE, WITH AGGRAVATING CIRCUMSTANCES OF BEING PROFESSIONALLY GASLIT BY A MAN WHO PROBABLY USES MAPQUEST
The Court finds itself in the EXCEEDINGLY rare position of issuing a ruling of sympathy, and frankly Reginald is uncomfortable with the sensation. You have committed no crime here except perhaps the crime of ASSUMING COMPETENCE in others, which, after seventeen years on this self-appointed bench, I can assure you is a fool's errand. This appraiser — this CARTOGRAPHIC MENACE who wandered in from 45 minutes away like a lost Uber driver with a tape measure — has essentially asked you to grade his homework AFTER he already turned it in wrong. A SHORT SALE, counsel. A SHORT SALE. I once ruled in Comparable Properties v. Basic Professional Standards (2019) that using a distressed sale as a comp is "the appraisal equivalent of judging a cooking competition using food from a dumpster fire." The Court has PERSONALLY experienced the sting of undervaluation — my gavel collection was once appraised at $47 by a man who clearly didn't understand the HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE of a limited-edition Brookstone ceremonial mallet — and the emotional damage was considerable. You are guilty only of being trapped in a system where you must now do someone else's job to fix their mistake, which is frankly the entire real estate industry's business model. The Roomba is circling with unusual agitation. This Court must adjourn immediately to draft a strongly-worded letter to the appraisal board that will absolutely be ignored.
Collateral Comp Damage
Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.
Advertisement