Advertisement
CONFESSION #0470 — APPRAISAL DISASTER
Wednesday, April 22, 2026
The photos looked great. Staged it myself, spent two days on that house. Buyer comes in at 485, we counter at 479, everyone's happy. Then the appraiser shows up and I swear to god he was there twelve minutes. Twelve. I know because I was sitting in my car waiting for him to leave.
He comes back at 431.
My seller calls me screaming. "You said 480 was conservative." I did say that. I believed it. The comp he used was a foreclosure from eight months ago that sold with a caved-in garage. I called the lender and said "Can you explain this comp to me" and she goes "I don't pick the appraiser."
Buyer won't make up the difference. Seller won't come down. Deal falls apart three days before closing.
The appraiser's report said "dated kitchen." The kitchen was renovated in 2019. I still have the receipts from when we staged it. Brand new receipts, sitting in a dead deal file.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF AGGRAVATED APPRAISAL VICTIMHOOD IN THE FIRST DEGREE WITH MALICIOUS RECEIPT HOARDING
The Court has reviewed this confession and finds itself PHYSICALLY ILL at the mention of a twelve-minute appraisal, a duration Reginald would not accept for a microwave burrito let alone a half-million dollar asset. You sat in your car and COUNTED THE MINUTES, which tells this Court everything it needs to know about your mental state and also your data plan situation. The appraiser cited a foreclosure with a CAVED-IN GARAGE as a comparable property, which is like comparing a golden retriever to a raccoon that died under a porch simply because both technically occupied residential land. And "dated kitchen" for a 2019 renovation? I once ruled against a man for calling shaker cabinets "tired" and I would do it AGAIN. However, and The Court says this with the gravity of a thousand gavels, you are not innocent here because you BELIEVED your own pricing and belief is not a defense, it is a HOBBY. You are hoarding receipts in a dead deal file like a squirrel preparing for a winter that will never come, and that is not professionalism, that is a coping mechanism. The Court sentences you to one hour of staring at that file before deleting it forever, and also I must leave now because Order the Roomba has breached the chambers again.
Appraisal Trauma Syndrome
Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.
Advertisement