Advertisement
CONFESSION #0584 — POST-CLOSE CATASTROPHE
Tuesday, June 2, 2026
The other agent emailed at 9pm. Night before closing. Subject line just says "issue." That's it. One word. Sellers had already moved out, already in Arizona, already emotionally gone from this transaction for like two weeks. Buyers did their final walkthrough that afternoon and apparently the basement has three inches of water in it. Three inches. The sump pump failed sometime between the sellers leaving and the walkthrough, which was maybe six days. Here's where it gets good. The sellers' agent tells me his clients "thought they mentioned" the sump pump was "temperamental." They thought they mentioned it. To who? When? Because it's not in the disclosure, I can tell you that much. I have the disclosure in front of me right now. Nothing about water, nothing about the pump, nothing about the basement being anything other than dry and perfect. Buyers want $8,000 off the price. Sellers are offering $2,000 because they "weren't even there when it happened." Like that's a defense. Like the house stopped being their responsibility because they drove to Phoenix. My broker's asking me what the disclosure says. I know what the disclosure says. The disclosure says nothing. That's the whole problem. Remediation company already came out, quoted twelve thousand for full treatment because there's mold starting behind the drywall. Starting. It's been six days. The title company keeps calling me like I have answers. Closing was supposed to be at ten tomorrow morning. Nobody's closing anything tomorrow morning.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF AGGRAVATED DISCLOSURE NEGLIGENCE AND CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT SELECTIVE AMNESIA IN THE FIRST DEGREE
The Court has reviewed this confession and finds itself PHYSICALLY ILL at the phrase "thought they mentioned." Thought they MENTIONED? To WHOM, the Arizona sunset? The Court once thought it mentioned to its dry cleaner that the shirts needed light starch, and you know what happened? MEDIUM STARCH, and Reginald had to wear those shirts anyway, and that is NOT THE SAME as three inches of basement water and incipient mold colonies forming their own HOA behind the drywall. This case reeks of the classic "we're in Phoenix now so physics doesn't apply" defense, thoroughly rejected in Zillow v. Laws of Moisture, 2019, where the Court held that water does not care about your emotional timeline or your U-Haul itinerary. The sellers knew that pump was "temperamental," which is realtor-speak for "actively dying and we're pretending not to notice," and now everyone's standing around a flooded basement playing hot potato with a twelve thousand dollar remediation quote while the title company calls you like you're the Oracle of Delphi. The Court finds the $2,000 offer personally offensive — that wouldn't even cover the emotional damages to the Roomba if Order had to traverse that basement. VERDICT RENDERED, and the Court must now go lie down because "thought they mentioned" has given Reginald a migraine that no amount of granite countertops can cure.
SCANDAL RATING: 7.8/10 Selective Memory Syndrome

Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.

Submit Anonymously → Subscribe to the Newsletter
Advertisement

← Back to the Full Docket