Advertisement
CONFESSION #0656 — APPRAISAL DISASTER
Tuesday, June 30, 2026
The appraisal came in low. Sixty-two thousand dollars low. On a house that had three comparable sales within a quarter mile, all within the last four months, all supporting our price. The appraiser used a comp from a completely different neighborhood, across the highway, backing up to a commercial strip mall. When my buyer's lender called to ask why, the appraiser said the houses were quote similar in style unquote.
Similar in style. They're both two-story colonials. You know what else is a two-story colonial? Half the houses in this entire county.
My sellers had already bought their next house. Already moved most of their furniture. The wife is eight months pregnant and they needed to close before the baby came because her maternity leave was unpaid and they couldn't carry two mortgages.
We disputed it. Sent a twelve-page rebuttal with photos, tax records, everything. The appraiser adjusted his value by eight thousand dollars. Eight. Out of sixty-two.
The buyers couldn't make up the gap. Sellers couldn't drop the price because they needed every dollar for their down payment on the new place. Deal fell apart three days before closing.
Found out later the appraiser had been in the business for six weeks. Six weeks. And he's making calls that blow up people's lives. Meanwhile I've been doing this for eleven years and I couldn't do a single thing about it. Couldn't appeal to anyone, couldn't go over his head, nothing.
The sellers had to rent their old house back from the new buyers for two months. Cost them nine thousand dollars.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF AGGRAVATED WITNESS TO APPRAISAL MALPRACTICE IN THE FIRST DEGREE WITH COMPOUNDING HELPLESSNESS
The Court has reviewed this testimony and frankly Reginald needs a moment because THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED TO MY COUSIN DEREK IN 2019 AND HE STILL BRINGS IT UP AT THANKSGIVING. Six weeks in the business and this arithmetic gremlin is out here using comps from across a HIGHWAY like geographic boundaries are merely suggestions, like the strip mall backing up to those poor comparison homes is just ambient commerce, like SIMILAR IN STYLE means anything when half the Eastern Seaboard is two-story colonials built by developers who had exactly one idea between 1985 and 2003. You submitted a TWELVE-PAGE REBUTTAL, which The Court notes is eleven pages more than this appraiser apparently read during his entire training period, and he adjusted by eight thousand dollars which is not a correction but an INSULT wearing mathematics as a disguise. The pregnant wife, the two mortgages, the nine thousand dollar rental nightmare, all of it sacrificed on the altar of a man who has been appraising homes for fewer weeks than most people have been on a diet they already quit. You are guilty only of being trapped in a system where eleven years of expertise means nothing against six weeks of credentialed incompetence, and The Court finds this so personally offensive that I must now go argue with my Roomba about jurisdiction because Order understands chain of title better than this appraiser understands comparable sales.
Comp-arative Injustice
Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.
Advertisement