Advertisement
CONFESSION #0767 — APPRAISAL DISASTER
Sunday, August 9, 2026
The open house went fine. Great turnout, two offers by Monday, we go under contract at 415. Everything's moving. Then the appraisal comes back at 382 and the whole thing collapses. Here's the part I don't tell the sellers: I knew the comps were weak. I knew it when I priced it. There was one sale on the same street from eight months ago that supported 415, but that house had a finished basement and a new roof. This one had neither. I just figured we'd get lucky, maybe the appraiser would use a different radius, pull from the subdivision over. They didn't. Buyers walked. Sellers had already put earnest money down on their new place. They're looking at me like I'm supposed to fix this and I'm standing in their kitchen going through the appeal process like that ever works. Should have priced it at 395. Would have appraised clean. Would have closed three weeks ago. Instead I got greedy for them and now everyone's stuck.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF PREMEDITATED APPRAISAL ROULETTE WITH RECKLESS DISREGARD FOR COMPARABLE REALITY
The Court has reviewed this confession and finds itself experiencing what can only be described as VISCERAL DISAPPOINTMENT, the same feeling Reginald had when he discovered his favorite open house snack table had been replaced with a single bowl of off-brand pretzels. You KNEW the comps were weak, you KNEW that basement was unfinished and that roof was held together by prayers and grandfathered insurance, and yet you chose to play appraiser lottery with your clients' earnest money and emotional wellbeing. This is not aggressive pricing, this is what we in the legal community call HOPING REAL HARD, which I remind you is not a recognized valuation methodology under the landmark decision of Reality v. Wishful Thinking, 2019. You gambled that some appraiser would squint at a different subdivision and go sure why not 415 seems fine, and now your sellers are standing in their own kitchen watching their equity evaporate while you mumble about appeal processes that work approximately never. The Court itself once overpriced a decorative gourd at a farmers market and the shame lingers to THIS DAY, so I understand the temptation, but understanding is not exoneration. You could have been a hero at 395, you could have closed clean and collected your commission and slept the sleep of the adequately competent, but instead you chose chaos and now everyone is stuck in what Reginald can only call a TRANSACTION PURGATORY OF YOUR OWN MAKING.
SCANDAL RATING: 6.8/10 Appraisal Arrogance

Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.

Submit Anonymously → Subscribe to the Newsletter
Advertisement

← Back to the Full Docket