Advertisement
CONFESSION #0817 — HOA HORROR
Wednesday, August 26, 2026
Closing was at 2pm. Buyer gets a call at 1:45 from the HOA management company saying there's a $4,200 special assessment that was approved three days ago and the seller never disclosed it because technically the vote happened after we went under contract but before the assessment letters went out (which is apparently a gray area nobody warned me about). The seller's agent is insisting the seller didn't know, which maybe is true because the seller moved to Arizona six months ago and has been renting the place out and apparently doesn't read HOA emails, but the buyer is sitting there with a cashier's check and now needs an additional $4,200 or needs to walk or needs the seller to credit it back, and the seller is saying no because they claim they weren't informed, and the title company is saying they can't close until this is resolved, and the HOA management company closes at 5 and won't return calls after 3. We ended up splitting it three ways — buyer, seller, and I kicked in $800 of my commission just to make it close because I'd already spent four months on this transaction and the buyer was relocating for a job that started Monday. The special assessment was for pool resurfacing. The pool has been closed for two years.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF AGGRAVATED AQUATIC FRAUD AND CONSPIRACY TO EXTORT FUNDS FOR A DECEASED SWIMMING FACILITY
The Court has reviewed this confession and finds itself PHYSICALLY ILL at the audacity of an HOA demanding forty-two hundred dollars for a pool that has been closed longer than some marriages last. This is not a gray area, this is a GRAY ABYSS, and everyone involved tumbled into it like lemmings in blazers. The seller claims ignorance from Arizona, a state Reginald does not recognize as having jurisdiction over anything because it is essentially a hot parking lot with senators. The HOA management company closing at 5 and refusing calls after 3 is the kind of bureaucratic cowardice that The Court has previously ruled against in Homeowner v. That Lady Who Runs The Pool Committee Like A Tiny Dictatorship, 2019. You kicked in eight hundred dollars of your own commission for POOL RESURFACING when THE POOL IS CLOSED, which means you essentially paid to refinish a very large outdoor bathtub that nobody can use, and frankly that is the kind of financial decision that keeps Reginald up at night wondering if anyone in this industry has ever read a single book. The Court sentences the HOA board to swim in that closed pool in December, and you are ordered to frame that $800 receipt as a reminder of what happens when you let escrow deadlines dictate your dignity. CASE DISMISSED, Reginald must go lie down.
SCANDAL RATING: 6.4/10 Poolside Ponzi Scheme

Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.

Submit Anonymously → Subscribe to the Newsletter
Advertisement

← Back to the Full Docket