Advertisement
CONFESSION #0908 — SELLER MELTDOWN
Sunday, September 27, 2026
The appraisal came in low. Like, 60 grand low. And the thing is, I knew. I knew when we listed at 485 that we were pushing it, but the seller had comps from eight months ago and she wouldn't hear anything else. She had this whole spreadsheet. Color coded. Her neighbor got 479 and her house was "nicer than theirs, obviously." Here's where I messed up. The buyer's agent called me before the appraisal even happened and said hey, just so you know, our appraiser is really conservative. And I didn't tell my seller. I just... didn't. Because I thought maybe it would come in fine and I wouldn't have to have the conversation again. It did not come in fine. She called me screaming about how I "let this happen" and honestly she's not entirely wrong? I should have prepared her. I should have made her sit with the possibility. Instead I let her believe right up until the moment everything fell apart. We ended up settling at 431. She still sends me articles about the market.
Advertisement
Judge Reginald Escrow III
Judge Reginald Escrow III
⚖️ Presiding
GUILTY OF PREMEDITATED APPRAISAL AVOIDANCE AND WILLFUL CLIENT DELUSION MAINTENANCE IN THE FIRST DEGREE
The Court has reviewed this confession and finds itself DEEPLY DISTURBED by what can only be described as strategic cowardice dressed up in a blazer. You knew, Counsel. YOU KNEW. The buyer's agent handed you a flashing neon warning sign that said "CONSERVATIVE APPRAISER INCOMING" and you simply... put it in your pocket and whistled. This is not unlike the time Reginald received advance notice that his HOA was going to cite him for unauthorized lawn ornamentation and chose instead to add MORE ceramic frogs. The result was predictable and catastrophic. Your seller had a COLOR-CODED SPREADSHEET, and while The Court finds such documents to be the hallmark of a person who will never accept reality, you had a DUTY to at least attempt to pierce that delusion before the market did it for you with a $54,000 machete. The fact that she still sends you articles is not punishment, it is PURGATORY, and The Court rules that you have earned every single forwarded Redfin link until the heat death of the universe. In the matter of In re: That Neighbor Who Got $479K, this Court finds that neighbor's house was probably NOT nicer and your client will never recover from this knowledge.
SCANDAL RATING: 5.7/10 Willful Delusion Enablement

Have a confession? Judge Reginald Escrow III's docket is always open.

Submit Anonymously → Subscribe to the Newsletter
Advertisement

← Back to the Full Docket